On Thursday, January 11, 2007 43-year-old Charles D. "Cully" Stimson, deputy assistant secretary of defense for (Guantánamo) detainee affairs, gave an interview on WFED AM 1050, a commercial radio station in the D.C. area. On air he opined that major law firms doing pro bono work defending Gitmo detainees should cause the firms' corporate clients to rethink their representation. Robert L. Pollock, a member of the editorial board of the Wall Street Journal, sang the same tune in Friday's WSJ. NEIL A. LEWIS ran the story in the New York Times.
Reaction was fast and furious, triggering "an instant torrent of anger from lawyers, legal ethics specialists and bar association officials, who said Friday that [Stimson's] comments were repellent and displayed an ignorance of the duties of lawyers to represent people in legal trouble." The president of the ABA said Stimson's message was "deeply offensive to members of the legal profession, and we hope to all Americans."
Senator Patrick J. Leahy (D-VT) wrote to President Bush, cc Sec. Def. Gates and Atty. Gen. Gonzales, asking Bush to "disavow Mr. Stimson's statements and take the appropriate action against this official."
No public reaction yet from Stimson, but on Saturday the Pentagon told AP's JOHN HEILPRIN that Stimson's views "do not represent the views of the Department of Defense or the thinking of its leadership."
Update: DAVID KURTZ reports that Stimson, Pollock, a DoD lawyer, a Marine Corps press flack and reporters from WFED AM 1050 were all together on a one-day round-trip junket from D.C. to Gitmo and back.
And the feedback continues: New York State Bar President Mark H. Alcott writes that Stimson's comments "constitute an impermissible effort on the part of a senior representative of one of the litigants (the United States government) to manipulate the outcome of these cases by seeking to deprive the detainees of vigorous counsel. By these statements and actions, Secretary Stimson has demonstrated that he is not fit for office. We commend the Justice Department and the Defense Department for disavowing Secretary Stimson, and we call upon the President to take appropriate action." And over 100 law school deans have signed a statement calling on the government to repudiate Stimson's remarks.
CODA: Stimson apologizes. But still under-reported, under-investigated: who cooked up the whole thing in the first place? And as JOSH WHITE reports, the "blame the lawyers" baton now passes to the hand of Attorney General Alberto Gonzales, who is upset with the slow pace of Gitmo litigation.